How can I get homeowners insurance after a nonrenewal in California?
Shop an admitted policy before the expiration date on the letter. If admitted carriers decline the house, place the California FAIR Plan for fire and a DIC policy for the gaps the dwelling form leaves out. A nonrenewal means that one insurer will not offer the next term. It is not a mid-term cancellation, and it is not a finding that the house cannot be insured. Admitted carriers we are appointed with — Stillwater and Bamboo — are writing new business again, subject to underwriting. We send the house to those appointments first. The FAIR Plan stays in place as the lawful backstop when the admitted market says no.
Do not cancel the current policy yourself to “start clean.” Keep it until the replacement is bound with an effective date that meets or beats the expiration. Call (209) 670-1556 the day the letter arrives. The step-by-step for a house already on the FAIR Plan is how to move from the FAIR Plan to one admitted policy. To see whether this address can move, check if you qualify.
Non-renewed? We shop the admitted carriers we are appointed with first. If they decline, we place FAIR Plan plus DIC so the term does not lapse.
Get a Quote
Call (209) 670-1556
How many California homeowners policies were non-renewed in 2023?
The Department of Insurance recorded 788,485 voluntary-market residential policies non-renewed or canceled in 2023. That count is in Appendix A of the fact sheet published January 13, 2025. The same row shows 724,037 new voluntary-market policies and 7,576,693 renewed ones. The fact sheet covers insurers writing $5 million or more in homeowners and dwelling-fire premium, about 98% of that market, and it excludes renters (HO-4) and condominium (HO-6) policies.
CDI is explicit about who starts a nonrenewal: “Past research shows that 75-80% of non-renewals are initiated by policyholders, for instance when they buy or sell a home or change insurance company. The remaining 20-25% of the total non-renewals are initiated by insurance companies.” Reasons CDI lists for the insurer-started share include wildfire and other risks outside a company’s guidelines, missing or fraudulent application information, claim history, or a company leaving the market. The 20–25% figure is CDI’s description of that past research. It is not a second 2023 tally printed next to the 788,485.
The FAIR Plan’s own column in that appendix is separate: 92,447 new FAIR Plan policies, 232,507 renewed, and 27,198 non-renewed or canceled in 2023. As of June 2026 the FAIR Plan reported 696,562 total policies in force (cfpnet.com key statistics, checked October 2, 2026).
What should I do the day the nonrenewal letter arrives?
Read the expiration date and the stated reason, keep the current policy in force, and start the replacement the same day. The house is still insured until the date on the notice, or longer if the notice was late. A gap is the problem to avoid. Many mortgage contracts require continuous hazard insurance. If coverage lapses, the lender can buy a policy and bill you for it. We do not quote a multiple for that lender-placed premium, because the amount is the lender’s, not a statewide schedule.
- Mark the expiration date and the reason the letter gives. Section 678 requires the specific reason.
- Do not call the old insurer and cancel early. You want the old term to run until the new one starts.
- Send the packet below so we can shop admitted carriers we are appointed with before that date.
- If those carriers decline, file the FAIR Plan application and a DIC quote timed to the same effective date.
What is the timeline after a California homeowners nonrenewal?
For a policy that expires on or after July 1, 2020, the insurer must deliver or mail the nonrenewal notice at least 75 days before expiration. That is Insurance Code §678(c)(1). If the insurer misses that window, §678(c)(2) keeps the existing policy in effect, with no change in terms, for 75 days from the date the notice is delivered or mailed. The insurer has to tell you that in the notice.
The notice itself has to include the specific reason or reasons for the nonrenewal (§678(a)(1)(B)). For a residential property policy expiring on or after July 1, 2021, §678(e) requires the nonrenewal to be accompanied by a consumer notice that describes the California FAIR Plan as basic property insurance when you cannot find coverage in the voluntary market. On and after July 1, 2022, mailing time under Code of Civil Procedure §1013 applies when the notice is mailed.
| When | What the law or the file requires | Source |
|---|
| At least 75 days before expiration | Insurer delivers or mails the nonrenewal notice, with the specific reason | Ins. Code §678(c)(1), §678(a)(1)(B) |
| If the notice is late | The current policy continues, unchanged, for 75 days from delivery or mailing | Ins. Code §678(c)(2) |
| Policies expiring on or after July 1, 2021 | The nonrenewal includes the statutory FAIR Plan consumer notice | Ins. Code §678(e) |
| Before the old term ends | Bind the replacement so the effective dates meet. Admitted policy first; FAIR Plan plus DIC if admitted carriers decline | Via Rapida placement practice |
What documents do I need after a homeowners nonrenewal?
The nonrenewal notice, the current declarations page, and the property facts an underwriter uses to rate the house. California law requires the insurer to send the notice. The rest is what we ask for so the admitted carriers we are appointed with can review the file. It is not a statutory checklist.
- The nonrenewal or cancellation notice, including the expiration date and the reason
- The current homeowners declarations page (limits, deductible, mortgagee)
- Property address, year built, square footage, stories, and construction
- Roof material and year, plus the year of electrical, plumbing, and heating updates
- Claims for about the last five years, on this house or on you
- Wildfire mitigation you have finished, with dates and photos, if the house is in or near a fire hazard zone
- If you are already on the FAIR Plan: that declarations page and any DIC declarations page
Hills addresses in the East Bay are a different file from a valley house. The local counts and ZIP detail are on homeowners insurance in the Oakland hills and East Bay. Statewide coverage basics are on what a California HO-3 covers.
When is the FAIR Plan plus a DIC policy the backstop?
When admitted carriers, including the carriers we are appointed with, decline the house. The FAIR Plan is the insurer of last resort created so a property owner who cannot buy fire insurance in the voluntary market still has a place to apply. It is a lawful market, not a penalty. The FAIR Plan dwelling policy is a named-peril fire policy. The FAIR Plan tells customers who need more complete property coverage to buy a difference-in-conditions policy, a flood policy, or an earthquake policy for the perils the dwelling form does not list. Liability, theft, and sudden water damage are the usual job of the DIC. Earthquake is not. Read whether earthquake insurance is worth it in California and what a FAIR Plan dwelling policy covers before you rely on fire-only coverage.
We do not promise that any house will be accepted. Underwriting is the carrier’s, and the FAIR Plan has its own condition guidelines. If you want the admitted-market check written up in one place, check if you qualify on Insurance City’s FAIR-exit page. This guide stays the how-to: notice, documents, timeline, and the order of markets.
What are the common questions after a California homeowners nonrenewal?
How can I get homeowners insurance after a nonrenewal in California?
Shop an admitted policy before the current term ends. Admitted carriers we are appointed with, Stillwater and Bamboo, are writing new business again, subject to underwriting. If the admitted market declines the house, the California FAIR Plan plus a DIC policy is the backstop. Do not cancel the current policy early. Call (209) 670-1556.
How many California homeowners policies were non-renewed in 2023?
The California Department of Insurance fact sheet published January 13, 2025 records 788,485 voluntary-market residential policies non-renewed or canceled in 2023. CDI writes that past research shows 75 to 80 percent of non-renewals are started by policyholders and the remaining 20 to 25 percent are started by insurers. That 20 to 25 percent is CDI's description of past research, not a separate 2023 count printed beside the 788,485.
How much notice does a California insurer have to give before a nonrenewal?
California Insurance Code section 678(c) requires the insurer to deliver or mail a nonrenewal notice at least 75 days before expiration for a policy that expires on or after July 1, 2020. If the notice is late, the existing policy stays in force, unchanged, for 75 days from the date the notice is delivered or mailed.
What documents do I need after a homeowners nonrenewal?
Send the nonrenewal notice, the current declarations page, the property address, year built, square footage, roof material and age, updates to electrical, plumbing, and heating, and claims for about the last five years. If you already have a FAIR Plan policy, include that declarations page and any DIC declarations page.
Is the FAIR Plan the only option after a nonrenewal?
No. The FAIR Plan is the lawful backstop when admitted carriers will not write the house. We shop admitted carriers we are appointed with first. If they decline, a FAIR Plan dwelling policy covers named fire perils, and a DIC policy is the usual companion for liability, theft, and water damage. Earthquake and flood stay separate.
Does a FAIR Plan policy cover earthquake after a nonrenewal?
No. The California FAIR Plan says its dwelling fire policy is a named-peril policy and tells customers to buy a separate earthquake policy, along with difference-in-conditions or flood coverage, when they need perils the dwelling policy does not list.
Where do these nonrenewal figures come from?
- CDI Fact Sheet: Summary on Residential Insurance Policies and the FAIR Plan, published January 13, 2025. Appendix A, 2023 voluntary-market non-renewed/canceled count of 788,485, and the overview’s 75–80% / 20–25% past-research statement. Checked October 2, 2026.
- California Insurance Code §678, nonrenewal notice timing and the FAIR Plan consumer notice. Checked October 2, 2026.
- California FAIR Plan, Dwelling. Named-peril dwelling policy; earthquake, flood, and DIC are separate purchases. Checked October 2, 2026.
- California FAIR Plan key statistics. Total policies in force 696,562 as of June 2026. Checked October 2, 2026.
Reviewed by Santo Militello, California-licensed Property & Casualty agent (CA License #1737723) and owner of Via Rapida Services — CA Insurance License #6003045. Our licensed team brings more than 70 years of combined insurance experience. Stillwater and Bamboo are named only as carriers we are appointed with. Acceptance is the insurer’s decision. The FAIR Plan is a lawful backstop, not a penalty. Last reviewed October 2, 2026.
