Serving Stockton · San Jose · San Rafael since 2013  |  ¡Hablamos Español!
Insurance City ↗209-670-1556
Via Rapida Insurance Blog · November 10, 2026 · Reading time: 8 min

Car Insurance After an At-Fault Accident in California

Updated

You had an at-fault accident in the last three years, and now the renewal came back higher or the company said it will not renew. California has written rules for who counts as at fault, how long it touches the Good Driver Discount, and when a company may drop you. Via Rapida Services quotes non-standard auto insurance for drivers in exactly this spot.

What happens to my car insurance after an at-fault accident in California?

If the insurer finds you were at least 51% at fault, and the accident caused an injury or more than $1,000 in property damage (10 CCR §2632.13), the premium can go up at renewal (CDI auto guide). A property-damage-only at-fault accident is one point on the three-year Good Driver test. An at-fault injury accident ends Good Driver eligibility for three years (Insurance Code §1861.025). A company may only non-renew for one of three reasons (§1861.03(c)). If standard companies say no, non-standard companies and then CAARP come next.

Get an auto quote

What does "principally at fault" mean in California?

It is a defined term, not the officer's opinion or the other driver's. Title 10, California Code of Regulations, §2632.13(b) says an insurer may not treat a driver as principally at fault unless the driver's actions or omissions were at least 51 percent of the legal cause of the accident. The accident also has to meet one of two sizes: it caused bodily injury or death, or, for a property-damage-only accident, the total loss or damage was more than $1,000.

Section 2632.13(c) presumes you were not principally at fault in these cases, unless the insurer shows otherwise:

The insurer that covered you at the time must investigate before it decides fault. Under §2632.13(e) it sends you a written notice with the basis for the decision. You have 30 days from receiving that notice to ask for reconsideration, and the insurer has 30 days to answer in writing, with someone other than the person who made the first call. Keep that letter. A new company you apply with has to confirm the fault decision with the prior insurer, rely on loss-exchange data with the details the rule lists, or use facts you confirm (§2632.13(f)).

How long does an at-fault accident affect the Good Driver Discount?

Three years. Insurance Code §1861.025 qualifies a driver for a Good Driver Discount policy if the driver has been licensed for the previous three years and, during those three years, has no more than one violation point and no principally at-fault accident with bodily injury or death. The Good Driver rate must be at least 20 percent below what the same insured would otherwise pay for the same coverage (§1861.02(b)(2)). 10 CCR §2632.13.1(b)(3) tells insurers how to count accidents for that test.

Your last three yearsGood Driver testRule
Accident where you were not principally at faultNo point. The CDI says no surcharge when it was not your fault.10 CCR §2632.13(b)–(c); CDI auto guide
One at-fault accident, property damage only, no ticketsOne point. Still eligible, because the limit is no more than one point.Ins. Code §1861.025(b)(1)(A)
At-fault property-damage accident plus a one-point ticket, or two at-fault property-damage accidentsTwo points. Not eligible until a point falls outside the three years.Ins. Code §1861.025(b)(1)
At-fault accident with bodily injury or deathNot eligible for three years, even with no other points.Ins. Code §1861.025(b)(3); 10 CCR §2632.13.1(b)(3)(B)

A DUI conviction runs on a separate ten-year look-back under §1861.025(c). That is its own topic; see car insurance after a DUI in California.

What changes at renewal after an at-fault accident?

Three things can change: the rate, the Good Driver Discount, and whether the company offers to renew at all.

Read the renewal for four items: which accident it lists, the date of that accident, whether the company says you were principally at fault, and whether you still have the Good Driver Discount. If the fault decision looks wrong, use the 30-day reconsideration in 10 CCR §2632.13(e)(2) before you shop.

When do non-standard companies or CAARP come in?

Think of it as three steps, and stop at the first one that works for you.

  1. Your current company renews. Compare the new premium against other offers before the renewal date.
  2. You lost the Good Driver Discount or got a nonrenewal. This is where non-standard auto insurance fits. Non-standard companies write drivers with recent at-fault accidents or points. Coverage is subject to underwriting. Our high-risk auto insurance page covers that market.
  3. No company will write you. The CDI auto guide says the California Automobile Assigned Risk Plan (CAARP) assigns you to a company, that every company licensed to sell auto insurance in California must accept CAARP, and that all CAARP companies charge the same premiums. Our guide on how CAARP works explains the steps.

Via Rapida Services checks steps 2 and 3 in the same conversation, in English or Spanish.

Get an auto quote

Is the DMV SR-1 report the same thing?

No. The SR-1 is a report you file with the DMV after certain accidents, and it has its own deadline. It does not decide fault for your insurer. Our SR-1 accident report guide covers the form. This page covers what the accident does to your insurance.

What should I bring for a quote after an at-fault accident?

  1. The renewal offer or the nonrenewal notice, with the expiration date.
  2. The insurer's written fault determination and the claim number, if you have them.
  3. The date of each accident and ticket in the last three years.
  4. The driver license number for every driver in the household.
  5. The VIN of each car and the current declarations page.

San Jose: 25 N 14th St, Ste 125, San Jose, CA 95112, Monday–Friday 10am–6pm, Saturday 10am–3pm. San Rafael: 9 Vivian Street, San Rafael, CA 94901, Monday–Friday 10am–6pm, Saturday 10am–3pm. Stockton: 956 W. Robinhood Dr, Stockton, CA 95207, Monday–Friday 10am–6pm. Call (209) 670-1556.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does principally at fault mean in California?

Under 10 CCR §2632.13(b), an insurer may treat a driver as principally at fault only if the driver's actions were at least 51 percent of the legal cause of the accident, and the accident caused bodily injury or death, or property damage over $1,000. The insurer must investigate, send a written notice with its reasons, and reconsider if you ask within 30 days.

Does one at-fault accident take away my Good Driver Discount?

Not always. Under Insurance Code §1861.025, a principally at-fault accident with property damage only counts as one violation point for three years, and a driver keeps Good Driver eligibility with no more than one point. A second point, from another accident or a ticket, ends eligibility. A principally at-fault accident with bodily injury or death ends eligibility for three years on its own.

How long does an at-fault accident affect my insurance in California?

For the Good Driver Discount, the look-back is the previous three years (Insurance Code §1861.025 and 10 CCR §2632.13.1). The driving safety record is the first rating factor under §1861.02(a). How long a surcharge stays on your premium follows the insurer's approved rating plan, so ask the company for the date the accident leaves its rating.

Can my insurer drop me after an at-fault accident?

Insurance Code §1861.03(c) allows a California auto cancellation or nonrenewal only for nonpayment, fraud or material misrepresentation, or a substantial increase in the hazard insured against. Under §663 the company must mail a written nonrenewal notice at least 30 days before the policy expires. Ask which of the three reasons it used.

When should I look at non-standard auto insurance or CAARP?

Shop non-standard companies when you lose the Good Driver Discount or get a nonrenewal. The CDI says that if you have had several accidents or tickets and no standard company will insure you, the California Automobile Assigned Risk Plan (CAARP) assigns you to a company. Via Rapida Services checks both.

Sources

Renewal went up after an accident?

Via Rapida Services is the brand of Insurance City Agency, LLC for non-standard auto insurance and DMV services. Stockton · San Jose · San Rafael — under one roof since 2013. Se habla español.

Get an Auto Quote Call 209-670-1556
Reviewed by Santo Militello, California-licensed Property & Casualty agent (CA License #1737723) and owner of Via Rapida Services (Insurance City Agency, LLC) — CA Insurance License #6003045. Via Rapida Services, Insurance City Agency, LLC · CA License #6003045. Call (209) 670-1556. The fault, Good Driver, and nonrenewal rules on this page were checked against the Insurance Code, 10 CCR §§2632.13 and 2632.13.1, and the CDI auto guide on November 9, 2026. Last reviewed 2026-11-10.
Ask EnzaQuotes & answers · 24/7
CallTextQuote